Johnny, I've never seen 358156 be a bad choice. Some some like it because of the gas check but I've seen it straighten out guns that were supposedly "inaccurate". I do have an attachment to 358429 and probably have more versions of it than any other design since there were more versions of 429 if you count the hollowpoint and hollowbase versions. I especially appreciate 429 when it's held to what it was originally designed for, the 38/44. I often shoot 38/44 loads in my 357s because I feel that 358429s greatest "magic" is in that platform. That said, Skeeters 358156 load performs the same way for me, and I've sold or traded off a lot of 429s because they just didn't seem to work well for me. Blashempy.
358432 is a fine design, and another one of those unsung heroes of Ideal/Lymans history in spite of Lymans neglect at making more loading data available for it. It is the only wadcutter design I'm aware of that can be loaded with a speedloader. Accuracy can be outstanding, and I know of competition shooters using it as their first choice for action shooting. I only have a couple of them at this point and need to get busy casting, which I haven't done any of for ages.
It all goes back to what Brad said in Post #2.
