357 revolver for deer

johnnyjr

Well-Known Member
I was looking up load data in my Lyman manual for the 358156 bullet. I see Lyman recommends using linotype for this bullet.
Why would the bullet have to be that hard from a 6 inch revolver. After all it is designed for a gas check.
 

Bret4207

At the casting bench in the sky. RIP Bret.
My normal alloy runs 12-13 Bhn, not that that tells you a lot really. Point is you can ignore that part of the Lyman equation. Use a fairly soft alloy, fit the bullet to the gun and enjoy. The 358156 is an extremely easy to use and versatile design.
 

todd

Well-Known Member

"357 revolver for deer"​


I really wish people would stop arming deer. They're destructive enough without giving them guns. :rofl:


we have deer that have Class 4 Body Armor and and an Kevlet Enhanced Combat helmet with a EoTech BinoNV-C BNVD on it. AND the use 50 Cal m107A1 Barrett rifles!!! :rofl:

we're doomed. Doomed. DOOMED i tell ya.

 

358156 hp

At large, whereabouts unknown.
The reason Lyman used either linotype or No.2 alloy was to have a consistent, easily reproduced alloy for pressure testing.
Truth. If mould manufacturers simply stated a weight, most of everything they sell would be returned as defective because the weight as advertised was incorrect. Taracorp magnum alloy was also used by some manufacturers as a "standard" alloy. Like Bret said, "try it". If you get your velocity up in the high end you could likely end up with some expansion as well.
 

Ben

Moderator
Staff member
Everyone establishes their own limits on the range that they can take an animal. I've always felt that with your pistol / rifle , if you're unable to put a bullet in the mouth of a coffee cup at a known distance, it may very well be difficult to make a quick, clean kill on the deer at that distance.