help finding a powder scale

Kevin Stenberg

Well-Known Member
I have always used an old Herters scale to weigh my powder charges. Its tiring watching the pointer keep going up and down.
What brands of scales have magnetic dampening in them?
 

462

California's Central Coast Amid The Insanity
I used to have an ancient and un-dampened Texan, and taped an appropriate sized piece of heavy paper over the slot. That settled the beam a lot quicker, but remained a patience trier.

My RCBS 5-0-5 stops in about two seconds, and reckon others will too. I would be very wary of the Lyman models that have plastic bodies.
 

Rick H

Well-Known Member
To be honest I don't trust digital scales. They are subject to power fluctuations, air currents etc. I have one that I use for bullet sorting and such but check it with either my old Herter's magnetically dampened or my RCBS 505 scales. I also have a set of Lyman check weights. I caught my electronic digital acting up as the batteries got weaker. I won't trust them for powder handling.

The only rifle I have ever seen that was blown up (Whitworth Mauser in 7mm Weatherby Mag.) was loaded with an RCBS electronic powder scale/measure. The same load that was used for over 30 yrs. We will never know what caused the failure for sure. The whole front receiver ring pealed open, the barrel flew forward and the stock was broke in three pieces. The action bent so that bolt is impossible to remove. The scope bent with the action. It is a miracle that the only injury to the shooter was a small nick on his nose. The owner had been using the RCBS unit for some years. When we checked the unit was fluctuating but not enough to cause the kind of catastrophic destruction of that rifle.
 

Jeff H

NW Ohio
I used to have an ancient and un-dampened Texan, and taped an appropriate sized piece of heavy paper over the slot. That settled the beam a lot quicker, but remained a patience trier.

My RCBS 5-0-5 stops in about two seconds, and reckon others will too. I would be very wary of the Lyman models that have plastic bodies.

Bought a 505 new in 1982 and still using it. I love it, although I grew up with Reddings.

I throw a charge in the pan, set the pan on the scale;
Let it settle, dump charge into case and set case in the shell-holder under the seating die;
Throw the next charge into the pan and set the pan on the scale;
Position and seat the bullet into the case in the shell-holder;
Remove cartridge from shell-holder to loading block;
glance at scale, dump charge into next case, set case in shell-holder.......

The scale has almost settled by the time I set the pan and turn my attention to the charged case in the shell-holder, but is absolutely still by the time I've seated a bullet and moved the cartridge to the loading block.

I do things this way for safety and consistency, so the very little time it takes for the beam to settle is way faster than I need. If I were mass-loading for a pop-pop-pop auto, I'd be throwing charges directly into cases and checking every tenth charge. Even in this situation, the wait is nothing. I no longer have any autos and "paper-plate-at-25" is not my objective, so that influences my perspective and tempo as well.
 

Brad

Benevolent Overlord and site owner
Staff member
I use a little Hornady battery powered digital. It just works.
For setting a measure it is the way to go. If I am trickling up to a charge the old RCBS or Lyman beam scale comes out.
 

Rick

Moderator
Staff member
I've two electronic scales, the RCBS and the Dillon and I frequently check powder weights between the two. On a rare occasion they will vary by a tenth of a grain, mostly they match perfectly. If one has an issue and is off they both have the identical issue at the same time. Unlikely.
 

Bret4207

At the casting bench in the sky. RIP Bret.
I started off with a non-dampened Redding. Then I got a dampened RCBS at some point. I don't trust the dampened scale as much as I trust the undampened one. I've always used my finger to slow the bounce and then let it settle. There's no difference in time that I can see.
 

JonB

Halcyon member
Kevin,
Is there any chance your old Herters beam scale has a oil dampening option?
Mine does, there is a cavity below the fulcrum to add oil for dampening...leave the oil out, no dampening.
It looks just like this one.

 

Ian

Notorious member
You don't have to wait for the oscillating motion to stop. If it swings three tenths high and three tenths low....then it will eventually stop on zero. Five high and one low, you're over two tenths.
 

Glaciers

Alaska Land of the Midnight Sun
Use a 304 RCBS double beam scale, plenty fast very accurate, been working for a lot of years. I could see an electronic scale if I was weighing every load. But as 462 says:

Electrons can be highly whimsical, but gravity has yet to fail me.

I have no reason to look further.
 

Kevin Stenberg

Well-Known Member
JonB that picture is close but not exactly like my scale. Yes i have a cheapie electric but i don't trust it for anything other than bullet weight separation. Yes i can use the arm on the left side of the pointer to reduce the swing distance. But that increases loading time.
The reason i am looking at dampened scales. I want to through the powder keep processing the case till the gunpowder is needed to pour into the case.
Ian i have watched the scale for the swing. But that takes time away from the act of loading a round. An no offence meant that is a guess. Seeing the pointer quickly stop at a desired spot is what i want.
I will be checking out all of the scales that have been suggested above. Thanks Kevin
 

Kevin Stenberg

Well-Known Member
What are the chances. Today i went to a gun auction and what should i see. An RCBS 5-10scale. An wouldn't you know the scale didn't come up for sale until the second to last item to be sold. At least i got it for a great price 25$. Now i just have to test it to see how accurate it is.
 

Mowgli Terry

Active Member
I had bought out an inventory of a pawn shop. In the reloading gear was a set of RCBS weights to check scales. These weights work out great when my RCBS digital starts acting the fool. I have a backup of two beam scales with magnetic dampening. To me the 10-10 RCBS is among the very best for what we do. These Ohaus beam scales work quickly. Ohaus made scales for RCBS. Some were sold under the Ohaus name. Same thing.
 

STIHL

Well-Known Member
RCBS or Hornady in beam scales. I prefer the digitalis, but it’s nice to have the old trusty beam to verify some stuff with. I have a hornady, and it has served well. Settles down in 2-3 seconds and is consistent and reliable.