Around here real horseradish is just ground roots, vinegar, and salt, Some add just a little onion. Creamy horseradish has mayo but that is not considered "real" in this area. And no sugar ever!
Yeah, same in my area.
My preparation recipe went something like this.
I thinly sliced the roots (so the fibers are short), then run those thin slices through a mini food processor.
The amount I can run is about the same size as a typical hamburger patty, so one batch is kind of small.
I sprinkle some canning salt on the mix, like I am lightly salting a hamburger patty.
I spin the food processor a bit more.
I let it sit for about 5 minutes (see note below)
I add of vinegar, and spin.
I add a bit more vinegar and spin.
I repeat until I get the pasty texture/consistency I want.
Put in Jar in the frig.
So, when I was researching on the interwebs, I see countless comments that the grinding starts a reaction that makes it spicy hot. They also say vinegar stops that reaction. So, they say to not add vinegar until near the end of grinding and letting it sit a bit before it's added.
I tasted some this evening, either it is getting better, or my taster was shot while I was processing it?
---
Ian,
In my area or my circle of friends, prepared Horseradish is typically used more like a ingredient, than a condiment...so in some instances a fat would be undesirable (like when canning spicy pickles). If I were to use as a condiment (like on a Hamburger), and I have, I mix it 50-50 with real Mayo.