I like the extra-thick, pinkish with white blotches kind of punkin for pies, in fact I buy them for jack o lanterns and then make pies as an excuse. The orange ones don't make great pies but they're ok cut into strips and baked in a pan with butter, brown sugar, and cinnamon. The deer here are to dumb to eat squash I guess, they'll eat the blossoms but not the vines or fruit. Possums however LOVE squash, the more rotten it is the better. Had a dog once that the only thing he loved more than ice cream was watermelon rind, never figured that one out.